Anatomy of a Scene: Much Ado About Nothing, Hero's Wedding
Don Pedro is a longtime friend of Leonato, Hero's father, and is also close to the helps Borachio and Don John deceive Claudio into thinking that Hero is. In this lesson we examine the relationship between Lady Hero and her father, Lord Leonato, in 'Much Ado About Nothing' as it goes through various stages. In Much Ado About Nothing, Leonato and Hero are depicted as having a close relationship. Claudio's intentions for this proposal. The type of relationship between Beatrice and Benedick was one of so Don Pedro, Prince of Aragon, decides to help Claudio and offers to.
This scene exposes both he and Claudio for what they are: Of course, this Leonato is actually angry, too. Whedon still includes the lines in which Leonato bemoans having but one child — this child — and Gregg also plays Leonato as physical with Hero, grasping her by the arms and bringing her face close to his.
If Branagh amplifies male violence and Whedon downplays it, the inverse is true for female agency.
After Hero has fainted and been revived, she issues a challenge. It is the most agency Hero demonstrates on-stage in the entire play. Branagh cuts this speech entirely; in his version of this scene Hero gets two lines in total and lots of inarticulate screaming. Whedon, on the other hands, includes this speech in its entirety and his direction emphasizes its importance.
By the time Hero concludes, Leonato has embraced her head and the two collapse to the ground, intertwined in a weepy embrace. Help, uncle … Uncle, Signor Benedick, Friar. Branagh cuts these lines completely again, Whedon leaves them in. Hero is brought to the ground well before Shakespeare has her faint. She is literally abject, spending most of her time on the ground as men loom over her.
This Hero also stands up for herself when Claudio is berating her; at one point, he literally holds out his arms as if to fend her off. A similar comparison can be made between the two versions of Beatrice. This moment suggests that Margaret realizes the mistake that has been made — and does nothing.
It is an interesting choice — it gives her a degree of complicity in what happens to Hero — but it becomes frustrating when you realize that, unlike the other characters of the play, she will never be able to explain her actions. Preceding the aborted wedding scene in the text is a sweet moment in which Margaret and Hero gently, wittily tease Beatrice about her affections for Benedick. This moment implies an intimacy and friendliness between the three women and has the refreshing effect of showing a woman other than Beatrice — and a serving woman, no less — who has a way with words.
Branagh cuts this scene entirely. In Act 1 Scene 1, he immediately starts to think about marriage and a future for them both. Claudio asks Benedick about his opinion of Hero.
Her Leonato asks Benedick weather he had noticed Hero and Benedick replies that he did but did not take much notice of her. This shows that Claudio is falling madly and deeply in love with Hero based on her looks and clearly not on her personality. The couple do not talk to each other but instantly Claudio is sure that Hero is the right girl for him.
Anatomy of a Scene: Much Ado About Nothing, Hero’s Wedding
Claudio instantly revels his feelings for Hero in a conversation between himself and Benedick. In the conversation they have Benedick can not come to terms or understand why Claudio feels so strongly for Hero. Unlike Benedick, Claudio revels and makes clear his feelings for Hero. The conversation between Benedick and Claudio is where the relationship between Claudio and Hero starts to develop.
After revealing his feelings for Hero, Claudio does not know what step to take next so Don Pedro, Prince of Aragon, decides to help Claudio and offers to disguise himself as Claudio to woo Hero for him. Now the plan was arranged the relationship between Hero and Claudio, if the plan works, should result in the two becoming a couple. Now Claudio believes he has no chance with Hero and that all hope of having a relationship with her has vanished.
I have broke with her father and his good will is obtained. This comes as an enormous shock to Claudio as he was fooled to believe that Don Pedro was wooing Hero for himself.
Claudio is silenced by the shock of the new he has been told, but soon the news sinks in and he lets out all of his joy. I give away myself for you, and dote up on the exchange. Claudio thought that he had lost all hope of being with Hero but now he has been told that he has her hand in marriage he is over the moon and shows that he is truly grateful for the opportunity.
A Book Review of Cold Mountain Essay He express how happy he is and how he is willing to give his future to the marriage. This is the point of the play where the relationship between Claudio and Hero officially begins. All is going well between them and we do not hear much about Hero and Claudio and they are only mentioned individually a few times until the wedding ceremony.
The ceremony does not go to plan. Claudio hears that Hero has been unfaithful and decides not to approach her with the allegations, instead leave it till the ceremony where he plans to announce it and embarrass Hero in font of the entire church.
We can now tell for certain that Claudio is immature, as he did not approach Don Pedro about the allegations that Don John had told him and now he does the same to Hero. There, Leonato, take her back again. Give this rotten orange to your friend.
Claudio explains all and confronts Hero, making a big scene in the Church. Claudio revels the rumours that he has heard earlier in Act 4 Scene 1. Hero denies all allegations and appears in a confused state.
Shortly after the confrontation, Hero faints and the wedding ceremony is abandoned. It now seems to the audience that all is lost between Hero and Claudio and word travels around that Hero has died.
All seems lost until Act 5 Scene 1 where Borachio, a follower of Don John, reveals to Claudio that Hero did not deceive or be unfaithful to him and in fact it was Margaret at the window.
Leonato then hears the truth and meets with Claudio and offers him the chance to marry his niece. In Act 5 Scene 4 Claudio prepares to meet his new wife to be. When the new bride unmasks her self it turns out to be Hero. This is a great twist in the play. They both finally reach the alter, for a second time, and finally get married. After studying the relationship between Hero and Claudio, I have established the similarities the couple share.
Firstly, I come to the conclusion that both Hero and Claudio are not confident people.
Dutiful Daughters and Willful Nieces
Claudio does not have the confidence to talk to Hero and approach himself. Therefore, Don Pedro does the talking for Claudio. Hero displays her unconfident manor in a different way. She is conventional in the relationship between herself and Claudio and acts like what people expect of her.
Secondly, Hero and Claudio base their feelings for each other mainly on the looks of one another. Both want to marry at the start of the play also. Lastly, Hero and Claudio act more immaturely, apposed to Beatrice and Benedick. I cannot state any clear differences between the couple.
When comparing the relationship between both couples there are similarities and differences. The main similarity and only similarity I can think of between both couples is the trickery used, resulting in both couple getting married. Beatrice and Benedick were tricked into confessing their love for one another and Claudio was tricked into thinking many things, although Claudio still ends up marrying Hero.
There are many differences between both couples.